How to choose a cold email agency: ten questions to ask before you sign
Choose a cold email agency by asking how it protects your main domain, who owns the sending setup, who answers the replies, and what you pay and for how long. A good agency answers each of these plainly, in writing, before you sign. These are the ten questions we would ask any agency, with how Chief Scale answers each one.
Will you send cold email from my main domain?
The answer should be no. Your main domain is the email your team and customers rely on. A cold email agency should send from separate domains set up only for outreach, so a deliverability problem never touches it.
Chief Scale never sends cold email from your main domain. We set up separate sending domains and inboxes and warm them before the first email goes out.
How long is the warm-up, and what happens during it?
New inboxes need about four weeks of warm-up before they send cold email. An agency that promises emails in the first week is skipping it.
With Chief Scale, no emails go out in the first month. During those four weeks we research and verify your lists and set up sending. If you are on Growth, LinkedIn outreach starts the day you sign up, because LinkedIn needs no warm-up.
Who owns the sending domains and inboxes?
Ask whose name the domains are registered in, who holds the admin login for the inboxes, and whether you keep both if you leave. If the agency owns them, your sending history leaves with the agency.
At Chief Scale, you pay for the sending domains and inboxes directly, so they're yours to keep if you leave.
Do you set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC on every sending domain?
These three records tell inbox providers that an email really comes from the domain it claims. Gmail has required sender authentication from bulk senders since February 2024. Ask the agency to confirm all three on every domain.
At Chief Scale, all three are set up and verified on every sending domain before warm-up starts.
How many domains and inboxes, and how many emails a month?
Volume tells you what you are paying for, and how that volume is spread across domains tells you whether it is sent safely. Ask for the monthly volume and the sending limit per domain.
Chief Scale's Growth plan sends from 11,000 emails a month, and Dominate starts at 35,000, all from separate warmed domains. We keep two to three inboxes on each domain and under 100 emails a day per domain.
Where do the lists come from, and who writes the emails?
Ask whether lists are researched for you or bought, whether every address is verified, and whether a person writes the emails or a tool does.
We build your lists after you sign up: the companies and people you sell to, filtered by industry, size, title and timing, using signals like hiring, funding and contract awards. We work in tools such as Apollo and Clay and verify every list before the first email. A person on our team writes the sequences. AI tools help with research and first drafts, and a person edits every message. We test more than one angle and keep what draws replies.
Who answers the replies?
Ask what happens in the hour after a prospect writes back. Replies are where meetings come from, so somebody specific should be reading them.
At Chief Scale every reply lands in one place, where it is read and tagged. When someone is interested, a person on our team answers with the whole thread in hand and offers a time. Every reply is tracked in a CRM.
Can it run alongside LinkedIn, and from whose profile?
Buyers often answer a founder on LinkedIn more readily than a vendor's email, so ask whether the agency runs both channels and from whose account.
On Growth, cold email runs with one LinkedIn profile, and Dominate pairs it with eight. Connection requests, messages and posts go out from your executives' own profiles: 200 connection requests a week, about 600 messages a month and 8 posts a month per profile, each post approved by you before it goes out. LinkedIn Sales Navigator runs on your own account and is paid by you. See how we run LinkedIn outreach.
What does it cost, and what is the minimum term?
Ask for the monthly price, the minimum term, the notice period and every cost outside the fee.
Growth, which is LinkedIn plus cold email, is $3,000 a month. Dominate is $14,790 a month. LinkedIn on its own is $1,500 a month per profile. Every plan is month to month with no minimum term, and you cancel with 30 days' notice. Two costs sit outside our fee: Sales Navigator on your LinkedIn account, and the sending domains and inboxes for cold email, which you pay for directly and keep. Full details are on the pricing page.
How will you report results, and what do you guarantee?
Ask how often you get a report, what it measures, and what happens when the numbers are weak. Be careful with guaranteed meeting counts, because nobody controls whether a buyer replies.
We do not guarantee meetings or revenue. We commit to the work: the setup, the research, the emails, the follow-up and a weekly report that states weak numbers as plainly as strong ones. Growth adds a strategy call every two weeks. Our published case studies show what happened for clients by industry. In one, an enterprise LMS platform averaged 18 meetings a month with director-level and more senior buyers by week 6, with no domain reputation problems and no spam complaints. Results differ by market and offer, and they are not a forecast.
Frequently asked questions
Should a cold email agency send from my own domain?
No. A cold email agency should send from separate domains set up and warmed for outreach. Your main domain should never be used for cold email.
How long does cold email warm-up take?
About four weeks. New inboxes need that long before they send cold email, so no emails should go out in the first month.
How much does a cold email agency cost?
At Chief Scale, cold email starts with the Growth plan at $3,000 a month, which also includes one LinkedIn profile. Every plan is month to month with no minimum term.
If you want these ten questions answered for your own market, book a call. We look at who you sell to and what you have tried, then recommend one plan, or tell you outbound is not the right move yet. Read more about how we run cold email.