Chief Scale
Published case study

18 qualified meetings a month with mid-market commercial insurance buyers

A commercial insurance brokerage filled its pipeline with property managers and business owners looking for better coverage terms.

InsuranceCold email and LinkedIn

9.2%Reply rate
18Meetings booked monthly
~14%Positive reply rate
47 daysTime to first meeting
Before

The brokerage had strong carrier relationships but struggled to win new business beyond referrals. Its team spent 15+ hours a week on manual prospecting (building lists, writing emails, tracking follow-ups) with little result. Cold calling connected with 2 to 3% of prospects, and most of those conversations went nowhere. The pipeline had dangerous gaps between referral cycles. The brokerage needed a predictable way to reach property managers, construction company owners and manufacturing operations directors who were shopping for commercial policies or unhappy with their coverage.

After

Within 47 days, the brokerage booked its first meeting, with a property management company overseeing 280 units. Reply rates settled at 9.2%, well above the 1 to 3% it had seen with previous vendors. By month three it averaged 18 qualified meetings a month with decision-makers controlling $2M+ in annual commercial premiums. The dedicated operator learned carrier appetites and pre-qualified prospects before handing them over. The brokerage closed four new accounts in the first 90 days, worth $127K in first-year commissions.

Figures as published in each client's case study. Results differ by market and offer; they are not a forecast.

“We went from cold calling spreadsheets to 18 qualified meetings a month with decision-makers who actually pick up.”

Insurance client, published case study

What we ran

  • Research on three buyer types, sized by units, revenue and headcount
  • Cold email from dedicated sending domains, rotated every three weeks
  • LinkedIn outreach through shared industry networks
  • Follow-up and pre-qualification of warm replies

We targeted three buyers: property managers with 50+ units, construction firm owners with $5M+ in revenue, and operations directors at manufacturing facilities with 100+ employees. Messaging focused on coverage gaps, premium reductions and claims support, the problems the client had heard on its own discovery calls. Email led with risk scenarios for each industry, LinkedIn outreach referred to shared connections in commercial real estate and contractor networks, and warm replies were followed up and booked as consultations. Email went out from dedicated sending domains, and messaging was rotated every three weeks based on the tone of replies.

Who we targeted

  • Property managers
  • Construction company owners
  • Manufacturing operations directors
  • Commercial real estate investors

Timeline

47 days to first meeting, 18 meetings a month by month three.

More case studies

Want to see if outbound fits your market?

Book a call. We look at who you sell to and what you have tried, and tell you plainly whether outbound will pay for you.